
I recently had the pleasure of interviewing New York Times Best-Selling author Cindy Woodsmall. The latest book in her Amish Vines and Orchards series just released his month. My wife is quick to point out that Cindy is one of her absolute favorite authors. The proof lies in how quickly she reads Cindy’s books. The below interview with Cindy was an inspiration to me as I read her answers about her writing journey and the path that God set her on. I hope you enjoy the interview.
Q: Everyone seems to have a “how I got published” story. What is yours?
I began writing the Amish story of my heart in 1999. I went to my first writers’ conference in 2002. Like so many others in life, I never really felt as if I fit in no matter where I went or what I was involved doing, but once at that conference, I felt as if I’d found my place—among other lovers of words and imaginative worlds. I came away so excited at the idea of getting the story inside my heart onto the written page in a way that captured readers minds and hearts, so my world became immersed in everything to do with writing. When I was on how best to convey on paper what was happening in the scene, I’d study book after book, talk to a writing mentor, and I would even dream about writing methods and solutions. Two years later I felt I was ready to turn in the first chapter to a few editors.
I was encouraged to receive wonderful feedback on my writing. I even had a potential offer to put me under contract if I’d write anything except Amish fiction. At the time only Beverly Lewis was writing Amish stories in trade fiction, and editors weren’t sure the market would hold strong for a second Amish author. Besides, they didn’t like the idea of a new writer following in the footsteps of such an established author.
I spent a few restless weeks deciding whether to follow the editor’s advice or stick to my Amish stories. It was a rough choice. It didn’t make sense for an unpublished writer to turn down the opportunity for a contract with a big publishing house. But after weeks of sleeplessness, I knew I had to continue with the story I’d written.
With that decision made, I made another—to pitch my story to every editor at every conference possible. Unfortunately, with one exception, the editors I spoke with were not interested in testing the market to see if it could support a second author writing Amish fiction.
In the spring of 2005, I submitted the first chapter of When the Heart Cries to an editor with WaterBrook Press (a division of Random House). By that time Wanda Brunstetter had moved into writing Amish stories for trade fiction. If there wasn’t room for me with only one Amish author, what would it do to my chances if there were two? But the editor for WaterBrook believed my story was strong enough to draw in readers regardless whether my setting and characters were based in Amish or not, so she asked me to turn in a full manuscript. I did, it passed the committee, and I had my first contract! That book was released in the fall of 2006.
Q: When did you realize you wanted to become a writer?
I actually struggled with the whole idea of writing professionally, even after I attended my first writers conference. To feel I fit in the Inspirational writing world was one thing, to feel I should pursue making that a career was another. Still, the hunger to understand story development and create stories began quite young.
One of my earliest childhood memories is of my mother reading to me before bedtime. After she left the room, I reworked every story she’d read to me. If Cinderella had been the ugly one, how would that change the outcome? If the stepsisters had been the nice ones, how would that have affected the story? I hated when I became too sleepy to continue working on those ideas and imaging the new story lines. That was the beginning of my love of thinking about plotlines and characterization.
But while in high school, I had an experience that turned me off to writing. Our English teacher gave the class a creative writing assignment, and my mother helped me brainstorm it. She was my first reader, and we spent days talking about it. Working on it with her was a lot of fun, but I had no idea the teacher was going to turn the assignments in to a countywide writing contest. All I wanted was a good grade on the assignment, and I received it. But the teacher never returned the story. Months later the school was called to the gymnasium for assembly, and a few awards were given out for various things. My name was called. My heart about stopped, and when I went up on stage, I was given a three-foot trophy. After the assembly was over, I stuffed the trophy into my locker, turned to a friend, and said, “I’ll never write again!” And I meant it. I was mortified! When it was time to go home that day, I hid the trophy under a sweater and put all writing behind me.
The lesson I eventually learned from that experience is that we as teachers and parents are often doomed J. Even when we try to encourage our children, the experience can undermine them. I just couldn’t deal with the spotlight or feeling I’d done something that special.
If I can take a side trail for a moment, I think that one experience is what led me to pray Psalm 127: 1 over my children continually: Except the Lord build the house, they labour in vain that build it: except the Lord keep the city, the watchman waketh but in vain.
In each prayer time I was yielding every good thing my husband and I did for my children to the God who knows how to take those building supplies and build according to what that child needs. He knows them. He must build their house. As a parent and teacher, I believe we should do everything we can for them, but I knew from my own experience that is simply not enough. I could sacrifice to give a great gift to them and that could undermine their motivation rather than adding to it. I could work beside them all throughout each day and that could inspire them or cause them to hate working. Only He can take those experiences and create what needs to be created.
So as a young woman set against writing, the years moved forward, stories continued to pound me, and I did everything I could to free myself of them—including whining to God to make them go away!
After many years of refusing to write, I slowly worked through many of my reservations, so once that was accomplished, I attended an American Christian Fiction writers’ conference (www.acfw.com). I took the time to learn how to get the story of my heart onto the written page. Then I went through the process of finding a publisher. It wasn’t easy, but I had peace the whole way, possibly because I would’ve been fine if I never became published. When I received my first contract, I prayed that enough books would sell that my publisher wouldn’t be disappointed. That was my only goal.
My first book ended up being a finalist in a contest I didn’t enter; it was for the ECPA Book of the Year contest, alongside three other authors, one of whom was Karen Kingsbury! It was a huge honor, but I immediately began struggling with the whole concept of writing and competition. That bit of a spotlight felt overwhelming and wrong. I spent weeks praying, trying to get the much-needed perspective. While in a restaurant with my family, I was distracted with praying about the situation when I saw the back of a man’s t-shirt. It said: let the competition begin and let God get the glory.
I gained a lot of peace that night. Oh, and Karen Kingsbury won the award J. Do I need to add that I was pleased for her and relieved for me? It seems that some aspects of who we are will never completely go away. We just have to deal with it.
There are a lot of roads in life, and we often take the wrong one, thinking it’s the right one. I’m very grateful that God kept directing me toward the “write” road.
Q: Tell me a little about your books.
I’ve written twelve works of fiction and one work of nonfiction, and I’m currently working on book three in my Amish Vines and Orchards series.
My real-life connections with Amish Mennonite and Old Order Amish families make devising the stories a lot of fun. I cherish the weeks I’ve spent staying with Amish families. The culture is so different from ours. The mindset so fully on keeping the Old Ways, and it’s such a blessing when writing to be able to draw from my time among the Plain people.
My co-author for my nonfiction book is an Old Order Amish woman named Miriam Flaud. Sometimes she and other Amish friends help me brainstorm my stories before I begin writing them. When I’m visiting an Old Order Amish home, there are times when an Amish woman will bring a baked good and we’ll have a slice along with a cup of coffee while she tells me an event from her own life that she thinks would make a good novel.
Q: What was your favorite book as a teen?
I’ll make a confession here, but it’ll be our secret, Brock, right? J My first love was nonfiction, and I don’t recall the titles or authors of most of those books, but I LOVED them, and I still remember the journeys they shared. I’d grab up whichever book I was reading before my feet hit the floor each morning, and I’d read throughout breakfast, chores, and while waiting for the bus. My mother was a volunteer on the mission board for our local church, and she taught teen missions, so she kept me stocked in stories of brave women and their struggle to be a worthy drop in the ocean. I also loved fan fiction from pop culture shows like Adam-12 and Hawaii Five-0.
As a young teen, I loved Johnny Tremain above all others! Followed by Island of the Blue Dolphins and Red Sails to Capri. As an older teen, I couldn’t get enough of Gone with the Wind and The Scarlet Letter.
Q: Describe your feelings when you opened the box and saw the first published copies of your very first book?
I would love to be able to tell you that I soared with elation. Many of my author friends danced around their homes and embraced the moment fully. But I didn’t even open the box. Hours later, when my husband came home, he opened it. He was excited and coaxed me into leaving my office to take a look at the book. I remember running my hands over the cool, smooth cover, and then returning to my office to work on book two. The deadline for the sequel was pressing in, and my energy and attention were funneled into that project. Looking back, I think I was scared that When the Heart Cries wouldn’t be enough of a success for the publisher to be pleased they’d put me under contract, so I brushed my personal feelings about it under the rug—as if the only thing that really mattered was the next project.
Q: What were some of the challenges for you writing your book?
My greatest challenge for my first series was the research. There are a lot of varied elements in a series, and I didn’t have a log of human resources to support me. I ended up spending time in Neonatal Intensive Care Unit with a nurse. I worked with a skilled OB/GYN. I rode Amtrak for eighteen hours. I spent spring break in Alliance, Ohio. I went to a birthing center, and also stayed with Old Order Amish friends for several weeks. And I exchanged numerous e-mails and had long phone calls with district attorneys, police, and I interviewed a room full of Old Order patriarchs. Interviewing the Old Order Amish men on the topics I needed was daunting, but they were gracious and honest. After that first series was written, I had a list of experts in various fields who I can turn to more readily than with my first novel. So treat your resource friends well. Lavish them with thanks, include them in your acknowledgment page, and send small gifts.
Q: What do you want readers to take away from your book?
Beautiful. Treasured. Energized strength. The kind of strength that comes through stirring faith, hope, and love. Those can reach beyond all reasonable boundaries and roadblocks, bringing into existence all we need. But each one of us must be renewed regularly or we grow weary, get out of sorts with God, and lose sight of finish line.
Q: In what ways does your faith impact how you approach writing?
Subtly and realistically, I hope. I aim to have a character-driven story, not an author or an agenda-driven one. From birth, people are on a journey, and by the time my story picks up, my characters are young people, often in their late teens to late twenties; I want to get into their hearts and minds. What have they learned about life? What do they want from life? What mistakes have they made?
I feel that people may love God and may be fully dedicated to him, but most don’t live their lives thinking: what is my Christian message to the world? Christ in us is a beautiful, ageless message, as unique as each person. So the question each character will inevitable answer is: how does His love and His will mixed with the strength and weakness of who I am come across in the life of a novel? Then, if a specific verse or message comes to the character, it will be organic in the same way when God speaks to us. Then faith becomes a part of the story.
Q: What can you tell us about any future releases you have planned?

The Winnowing Season released April 2. It’s the second book in the Amish Vines and Orchards series. Book three, For Every Season, will release in the fall.
A sneak peek into The Winnowing Season ~
The tornado that devastated Kings’ Orchard pushed Rhoda, Samuel, and Jacob to make a new start in Maine. Are they strong enough to withstand the challenges of establishing an Amish community—and brave enough to face the secrets that move with them?
On the eve of their departure to begin a new Old Order Amish community outside of Unity, Maine, Rhoda Byler is shocked to discover that choices made by her business partner and friend, Samuel King, have placed her and her unusual gifts directly into the path of her district’s bishop and preachers. She is furious with Samuel and is fearful that the Kings will be influenced by the way her leaders see her, and not what they know to be true—that Rhoda’s intuition is a gift from God.
Jacob King won’t be swayed by community speculation. He loves Rhoda, believes in her, and wants to build a future with her in Maine. But when the ghosts of his past come calling and require him to fulfill a great debt, can he shake their hold before it destroys what he has with Rhoda? Samuel has a secret of his own—one he’ll go to great lengths to keep hidden, even if it means alienating those closest to him. Throwing himself into rehabilitating the once-abandoned orchard, Samuel turns to a surprising new ally.
Can the three faithfully follow God’s leading and build a new home and orchard in Maine? Or will this new beginning lead to more ruin and heartbreak?
To read an excerpt or to order The Winnowing Season, go to: http://www.cindywoodsmall.com/books/amish-vines-and-orchards-series/the-winnowing-season/
As for my future plans, I can’t share that right now, but if I get my “hopes,” I’ll begin a new series in about two years that will take the author and reader into something very special.
Q: Favorite place to vacation?
Panama City Beach, Florida! My husband and I and our children have been going each year for about twenty-five years. Wow, have we seen changes to that vacation spot, most have been for the better. We continue to gather there once a year. It gets more challenging as our sons had to coordinate time around college and work, and we schedule around their wives needs also. We draw names ahead of time, and while there, we celebrate everyone’s birthday. It’s such a treasured time for us. I know it’s not the extravagant vacation many dream of, but to have a week each year to spend with the whole family, well, it’s always been a dream for my husband and myself. We talked about it when our children were quite little. This past summer was our first vacation with our first grandchild. I’m truly blessed to have such wonderful daughters-in-law, and I do my best to live in a way that they can say the same of their mother-in-law! I love those young women so much. I had concerns they may not want to go on a yearly vacation with their in-laws, but as it turned out they love it as much as we do.
Q: Favorite color?
Almost any shade of purple, with a particular affinity for magenta!
Q: Do you listen to music while you write? If so what are some examples?
I really enjoy music and wish I could listen all day long, but after just a few minutes, I find myself getting distracted and frustrated with the “noise,” even when it’s a song I’d appreciate under different circumstances. I usually need quiet to be able to write at my best, although because I’ve spent so many years writing while other things were going on in the house, if the house is empty, which happens these days—no homeschooling children, my husband has returned to work (Yay!), and our youngest has recently flown the nest—it gets too quiet! J

Q: Coke or Pepsi? Of those two choices, coke! I live outside of Atlanta, which is where Coca-Cola was invented and marketed in the eighteen hundreds, and where its headquarters still is, so in the South, for many decades, when a server asked what you wanted to drink, Southerners would say coke, and then the server would ask, what kind of coke? Meaning Sprite, Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, etc. But with today’s transient society, I think most Southerners have been broken of that habit. Those servers who’d come to Georgia from other regions would look at us like we were stupid for saying we wanted a coke when we meant a sprite or something. Of course we knew why we had that habit J. It’s the real thing!
Q: Favorite season? I LOVE fall and spring most of all, but any season that doesn’t involve the dog days of summer refreshes me. I simply endure those dog days. But that’s because I live in the South, and, with few exceptions, I keep my windows open year round. In winter I look like snow skier while writing. I did this while growing up too. I’d open my windows year round and have to keep a towel wedged under my bedroom door so I wasn’t allowing cold air or heat into the rest of the house. I don’t feel truly alive unless I can see, hear, and feel the outdoors, even if the windows are only opened an inch or two in really cold or hot weather.
Q: Do you have a particular drink or food you consume when you write? When I’m under a tight deadline, which can last for six to eight weeks at a time, I sip on sweet tea, preferably Chick-fil-A sweet tea. The tea is delicious and the foam cups keeps the ice from easily melting, and condensation rarely forms on the outside of their cups, unlike all others—which is important when one gets a large glass in the morning and is still sipping on it at nearly midnight. J
Like this:
Like Loading...